Men who are over-confident about their investing knowledge run the risk of falling victim to an investment fraud, according to recent data collected by Canadian securities regulators and research into a multi-million dollar investment scheme.
The British Columbia Securities Commission (BCSC) took a further look at research conducted by the Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) in 2006 and 2007 and found that men are far more confident than women when it comes to making investment decisions (scoring a net investment confidence rating of plus-36 per cent compared to minus-14 per cent for women).
The fact that men – particularly affluent, middle-aged men – are confident investors reaffirms findings from the 2005 Eron Mortgage Study, an analysis of an investment fraud that raised over $240-million from investors. The Eron study found that middle-aged, affluent men are prone to taking economic risks, making them a group that is susceptible to investment fraud. Furthermore, the CSA research found that men are more likely than women to believe investing is a gamble and that it is okay to bend the rules.
“It is important to be confident when investing, but over-confidence may get you into trouble,” says Patricia Bowles, BCSC director, communications and education. “Those who described themselves as highly knowledgeable investors – often cocky, affluent men in their 50s – were hit hard by the Eron scheme. These people lost more than twice as much as the other Eron investors.”
The 2007 CSA study also found that 46 per cent of men reported someone approached them with a fraudulent investment, compared with 36 per cent of women. Of those approached, 15 per cent of men were defrauded compared to 10 per cent of women. In fact, men who have fallen victim to an investment scam are more likely to have been defrauded more than once – 32 per cent compared to 20 per cent for women.
Although men may be more at risk of falling victim to a fraud than women, the CSA research shows that men tend to be more familiar than women with their most recent investment and the risk associated with it. Men are also more likely to conduct independent research and are less likely to invest “as soon as they heard” about an investment opportunity.
“It is good to see men exhibiting the knowledge and habits that lead to making sound investment decisions,” says Bowles. “However, everyone needs to understand that bending the rules and taking chances on something that sounds ‘too good to be true’ may cost them more than just money.”
In the 2007 CSA study, victims of investment fraud reported negative impacts to their health, their personal relationships, and their trust in others.
The CSA commissioned Innovative Research Group Inc., a national public opinion research firm, to conduct the 2007 CSA Investor Study: Understanding the Social Impact of Investment Fraud and the 2006 CSA Investor Index.
The research is based on two national online surveys of more than 5,000 Canadians, 18 years of age or older, in both 2006 and 2007. The margin-of-error for each survey (5,568 and 5,868 interviews respectively) is considered accurate within ±1.3 per cent, 19 times out of 20.
InvestRight is the BCSC’s one-stop resource for investors to educate themselves on how to make informed investment decisions. Its comprehensive website at InvestRight.org provides a wide range of tools to help investors develop critical thinking skills they need to protect themselves. If you have questions or problems with an investment or a financial adviser, please call 604-899-6854 or 1-800-373-6393 (toll-free in BC & Alberta).
The BCSC is the independent provincial government agency responsible for regulating trading in securities within the province. If you have questions, contact Ken Gracey, media relations, 604-899-6577.
The recent collapse of MF Global once more reminded us that we have in place an important safety net for investors whose brokerage firm faces bankruptcy. MF Global, as US based securities firm, collapsed on October 31, 2011 after making disastrous bets on European debt. Its Canadian subsidiary filed for bankruptcy four days later. […]
Interesting piece in the weekend edition of Montreal’s The Gazette about Carlo Ponzi (sometimes referred to as Charles Ponzi) and his connection to the Quebec city. By now – thanks to Bernie Madoff – how a Ponzi scheme works is well known: It takes money from new investors to pay existing investors. There’s no real […]